Scammers for Crammers
An Introduction to Pay to Play Corporations
Imagine a normal morning. You wake up, scrub your teeth with foamy blue gel to get rid of your morning breath, then proceed to stare dazedly at a pile of mail because who still sends letters in this day and age?
Only, lo and behold. There’s an abnormally thick envelope sitting on the table. An envelope with a doctor’s name in the corner and the words “Harvard Square” written in Times New Roman on the back. Harvard Square, by the way, is not actually part of Harvard University. It’s just down the street.
For reference, that’s like saying you’ve performed on Broadway when in actuality you once juggled pinto beans to off-key violin on the corner of Broadway and Pearl.
Let’s say you open it, as people tend to do with envelopes, only to find that you have been “selected for recognition as a Delegate” (note the capital letter) for your school at the “Congress of Future Medical Leaders” because of your “leadership potential” and “outstanding grades.”
If this scenario sounds too good to be true, that’s probably because it is.
If you tend to read the letters you receive, instead of just basking in the freedom of being able to throw those letters away, then you would probably notice that these “outstanding grades” they speak of can actually be described as “a minimum 3.25,” a qualification that definitely seems laudable enough to be recognized as qualified for this “Congress of Future Medical Leaders” who will be the “promising future leaders of medicine.”
You will simultaneously notice that there are far too many papers in this overly, obnoxiously thick envelope, which may be a possible reason for why it is so unnecessarily thick and important-feeling.
Within these papers, scattered messily in several unreasonably distant locations, you will discover that in order to attend this “Congress of Future Medical Leaders,” in which you witness a surgery and meet several new people you have never heard of, you will need to:
- Verify that your GPA does, in fact, meet the standard of the minimum 3.25 requirement, and
- Give them money, as indicated by the section on a much thinner sheet of off-gray paper that addresses the possibility of refunds. There was no mention of price anywhere within the remainder of the insurmountable mound of papers.
- Unless there was, and you just missed it, because you are currently drowning within the remainder of said insurmountable mound of papers.
- Oh there it is. That’s a lot of money.
If you hold enough interest to continue sifting through this mountain of papers, you will find that the price of this three-day romp in surgical prepaid paradise (dubbed “tuition” by their website) is $985. If you happen to check the website on top of that, you will find that this “tuition” does not cover board, transportation, or meals. You will also find the cost of one “transferable college credit” (advertised within one of the fancier papers located within the envelope) to be an extra $275.
“The Congress,” as I’ve taken to calling it, is not alone in sending out these overly weighty letters however. Joining it in its ranks are such wordy names as the Presidential Youth Inaugural Conference, the National Society of High School Scholars, and the National Academy of Future Scientists and Technologists. “Pay-to-play” organizations such as these have been referenced in national publications going back decades, each enunciating their inherent scamminess. And yet, high schoolers still open golden-embossed envelopes gushing about the honor and the privilege of being selected, envelopes that take the spotlight off opportunities and scholarships that are actually merit-based.
It’s probably summed up best by collegeconfidential.com user Chirality, who we can only hope is as reliable as their spotlessly empty bio page says they are: “I won’t be attending this event out of principle.”
BHS counsellor Marc Goulet, a perhaps more credible source, describes it more tactfully: “I think some of [these organizations] — I can’t speak for all of them, I’d have to see specific ones — I’d say some of them prey on our instinct for recognition, but at a cost to us.”
But perhaps BHS student Lara Spijkerman put it best, during an overly-loud block lunch interview in which the word ‘Scientology’ was brought up in a rather interesting side conversation two feet immediately to the left. “If you’re able to pay for this experience,” she said, struggling to be heard over the mass chaos that is block lunch, “then you’re able to pay for lots of other things that would look good on a resume.”
And there you have it. That mound of gold-embossed papers really is as useless as everyone thought it was. So kick back, relax, and revel in the freedom of throwing it all away.
Or recycling it. Your preference.
A senior at Boulder High, Jac has had an interest in journalism since her middle school years, an interest which has only been exacerbated by the current presidential stance against honest reporting. This year, she hopes to improve her own writing skills and help The Owl gain a more sizable readership.
In class, Jac has a healthy interest in math and science and a slightly more bizarre interest in discovering and inventing Latin insults she will probably never use. She also spends a fair amount of time tutoring and taking the bus.
When she’s not at school or doing homework, Jac enjoys reading, cooking, and defending the stylistic usage of sentence fragments. And while some Owlies may...
Niomi • Sep 22, 2021 at 11:42 am
Oh wow! I recently received one of these in the mail and got excited! Until I saw the three payments of $325 and thought it too good to be true, this article confirmed it for me.
anon • Sep 13, 2021 at 9:24 pm
i am so ridiculously thankful for this article. i got one of these today and it seemed far too fancy and out of the blue for me. did my research and it didn’t take long to find articles and reddit pages just like this one. sucks i got excited for nothing but at least now i can bring it to class and let all my classmates know not to get excited like i did if they receive one aswell
Jessabelle • Jan 31, 2021 at 6:24 pm
My daughter recently got this letter. We were pretty sure it was a scam but weren’t sure. Thanks for clarifying. She is only a freshman who has in no way shown interest in Harvard or medical programs. Again thank you so much for this article it was very helpful.
Darla Mouat • Nov 18, 2020 at 3:17 pm
This made me laugh so hard…my 15-year-old daughter received this envelope in the mail last week! I was instantly reminded of a time 10 years ago, when her older sister received a similarly embossed envelope whose contents invited her to be a Wyoming Ambassador of Music and how that particular honor ended up costing her dad and I over $3,000 to sing her way through Europe! ! Anyways – back then we didn’t have such things as “Google” (or if we did, I didn’t know it.) This time, you bet I Googled “Congress of Future Medical Leaders” and was immediately interested in some of the BBB complaints. For instance, the 2020 Conference of course couldn’t happen in person due to Covid…but the Congress isn’t issuing refunds because the conference wasn’t “cancelled.” It was “modified” to be three days of Webinars / Zooms!! And the Congress pretended that this was an effective alternative. Anyways. My kid watches a lot of Grey’s Anatomy and wants to be the next Grey. Thank goodness for your article. Appreciate it!
jasmine todd • Oct 11, 2020 at 10:08 am
and they wanna 325 dollars for this crap
Joe • Jan 26, 2022 at 6:36 am
3 payments of $325